Nada Surf return with another solid, classic collection of indie pop

Nada Surf are, decidedly, one of the most classic Indie pop rock bands of our generation. From their earliest records way back in their discography to their later material, the band has been consistent. I was blown away at how loud and charged their live performances were, how tight the band is; they're easily one of the most underrated bands in today's pop rock.

"Moon Mirror" is their latest incantation, their last since 2021's "Cycle Through," and the haunting melodies and Matthew Caw's melancholy voice shines brighter than ever. Every time I listen, a new favorite comes around; at the time of writing,"New Propeller" is sending me into a blissful, state; you can feel the melancholic lyrics Caw pours out are as genuine as its gets. The guitars and production are tight, the hooks compelling, and the songs memorable.

After listening to the record on repeat a few times today, it wasn't until I really let the closer "Floater" sink in that I started questioning myself; is this the best Nada Surf record? It's really hard to say; come back to me in a few weeks when I've matched the play counts of their other records and I'll know for sure. Either way, "Moon Mirror" is lending itself to be one of those records where you don't hear anything distinctly new, different, or changed––but you can't turn it off. Bless you, Nada Surf, you did it again.